Blog Layout

Finding the Right Balance

Greg Roskovensky • Aug 17, 2015

Today’s post was written by a good friend of mine, AJ Grzesiak.  AJ is a physical therapist with extensive outpatient experience and expertise in physical therapy and strength and conditioning.

 

Strength and Conditioning:  Finding the Right Balance

The goal of any training program is to improve physical performance.  Athletes are always looking for an edge that will enhance their ability to perform and ultimately succeed, and often times rely on personal trainers, athletic trainers, strength and conditioning coaches, and physical therapists to help them optimize their functional capabilities.  Developing appropriate training programs can pay huge dividends by not only improving sport specific skill sets and physical fitness, but by also preventing injury and rehabilitating existing ailments.  If our training programs are not incorporating activities focused on keeping the athlete on the field or in the game we are doing an injustice to the core definition of physical performance by potentially inhibiting the athletes “ability to perform the task or sport” and setting them up for failure, or at the very least injury, long term.

The application of neuromuscular training is often overlooked in strength and conditioning programs.  The benefits of strengthening activities, agility training, speed drills, and plyometric exercises on physical performance measures such as shuttle run and vertical jump are well documented and routinely used.  However, good neuromuscular control is achieved by the intricate balance of adequate strength and mobility, efficient joint mechanics, kinesthetic awareness, and an adaptive motor control system.  Incorporating exercises aimed at improving the body’s ability to attain dynamic balance goes a long way in establishing the functional movement patterns and joint stability needed to prevent injury, return to peak performance following injury, and simply put maximize overall functional performance.

Here is what the research tells us:

  • Dynamic balance of young hockey players displayed significant relationship with maximum skating speed. 1
  • Static unipedal balance of elite golfers correlated with improved performance measures of greens in regulation and average putt distance after a chip shot. 1
  • Soccer players with poor balance had almost 4 times the number of ankle injuries. 2
  • Youth male and female basketball players with poor balance had about 7 times as many ankle sprains as those with good balance. 3
  • Baseball players with ulnar collateral ligament injury (“Tommy John” surgery sound familiar?) have decreased balance on both stance and lead limbs. 4

Now for a few facts concerning the hot topic of Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) injury in the knee, which is becoming all too commonplace at all levels of athletic competition and training:

  • Only 44% of athletes successfully returned to sport after an average of 41.5 months following ACL reconstruction. 5
  • Aberrant neuromuscular and biomechanical patterns are commonly seen up to 2 years after ACL reconstruction, and these deficits are highly predictive of the risk of second ACL injury. 6
  • Recovery of normal strength symmetry after ACL reconstruction does not translate to appropriate neuromuscular control as healthy athletic females demonstrated high-risk biomechanical features despite adequate leg-to-leg strength symmetry. 7
  • Neuromuscular training programs can effectively reduce primary ACL injury prevalence by 73%. 6

In looking at these bullet points you can see that incorporating balance training to enhance sensorimotor processing not only prevents injury but also optimizes functional performance measures specific to sport.  It is also important to note that activities we may not initially associate with needing excellent balance due to the predominance of upper extremity use can also benefit greatly from neuromuscular training.  Part of the reason for this is that poor balance may significantly affect an athlete’s ability to transfer energy along the kinetic chain, resulting in dysfunctional movement and increased stresses at various segments. 4

When developing a training program or providing exercise prescription remember that balance training should complement aspects of resistance training, core strength, speed, plyometrics, agility, and flexibility.  Starting with gross movements and progressing into functionally specific movement patterns is highly important for skill transfer, and in terms of balance training this can be applied to both stable and unstable surface training.  Studies have shown that unstable surface training exercises significantly decrease non-contact ACL injury, reduce risk of ankle injury, and increases single leg stability. 8  Working to improve body awareness, postural control, and movement biomechanics  through unstable surface training acts as a good front-line approach at injury prevention as well as providing performance enhancement effects for sport.  As movement and sport performance experts this should be our goal when developing any training program.  Remember, physical performance is multifactorial and preventing injury is the start of it all!

 

Written by:  A.J. Grzesiak, PT, DPT, OCS

Doctor of Physical Therapy

Orthopedic Clinical Specialist

A.J. is a Physical Therapist who specializes in treating musculoskeletal dysfunction and injury.  He has worked in both private practice and institutional settings treating patients that are recovering from injury and surgery, looking to improve performance and prevent injury, dealing with chronic pain conditions, vestibular rehabilitation, balance impairments and fall prevention.

 

A.J and his wife, Melissa who is also a Physical Therapist, are the inventors of the STEPRIGHT™ Stability System.  STEPRIGHT™ is a functional balance training product providing an unstable surface that allows for dynamic and translational stability training while maintaining the normal movement mechanics.  Visit www.steprightstability.com for more information.

 

References:

 

  1. Hrysomallis C. Balance ability and athletic performance.  Sports Med.  2011;41(3):221-232.
  2. Tropp H, Ekstrand J, Gillquist J. Stabilometry in functional instability of the ankle and its value in predicting injury.  Med Sci Sports Exer.  1984;16(1):64-66.
  3. McGuine TA, Greene JJ, Best T, et al. Balance as a predictor of ankle injuries in high school basketball players.  Clin J Sport Med.  2000 Oct; 10(4):239-244.
  4. Garrison JC, Arnold A, Macko MJ, Conway JE. Baseball players diagnosed with ulnar collateral ligament tears demonstrate decreased balance compared to healthy controls.  JOSPT.  2013;43(10):752-758.
  5. Ardern CL, Webster KE, Taylor NF, Feller JA. Return to sport following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery:  a systematic review and meta-analysis of the state of play.  Br J Sports Med.  2011;45:595-606.
  6. Sugimoto D, Myer GD, McKeon JM, Hewett TE. Evaluation of the effectiveness of neuromuscular training to reduce anterior cruciate ligament injury in female athletes:  a critical review of relative risk reduction and numbers-needed-to-treat analyses.  Br J Sports Med.  2012;46:979-988.
  7. Hewett TE, Myer GD, Ford KR, et al. Biomechanical measures of neuromuscular control and valgus loading of the knee predict anterior cruciate ligament injury risk in female athletes:  a prospective study.  Am J Sports Med.  2055;33:492-501.
  8. Myer GD, Ford KR, Palumbo JP, Hewett TE. Neuromuscular training improves performance and lower-extremity biomechanics in female athletes.  J Strength Cond Res.  2005;19(1):51-60.

 

Note from Greg:  I think AJ touched on many good points.  Unstable surface training got pretty big not to long ago and people have more recently started pushing it aside completely.  I think the point is, that all good training programs have many different tasks/types of training incorporated into them.  There is a plethora of research showing that unstable surface training is great for injury prevention and is used in the rehab world all the time.

29 Mar, 2022
So far I’ve introduced a little about the “non-diet” approach , as well as the Diet Cycle , which many people find themselves stuck in when using a restrictive “diet” approach to food and health. For some of those people, the idea of eating what they love and “giving up” on diet or weight loss doesn’t seem like an option, understandably. We face a LOT of pressure, day after day, to eat “clean” and lose weight. That pressure may come from well-intentioned family, friends, and healthcare professionals who are concerned about our health (more on that later); or from fear-inducing headlines that compare sugar to poison; or from photo-shopped & face-tuned ads on Instagram of celebrities selling their flat tummy tea or shapewear. We are surrounded by Diet Culture, and are forced to engage with it- no matter if it’s coming from our loved ones, acquaintances, coworkers, or even strangers. What exactly is Diet Culture? You might have an idea just from the sound of it... Messaging that promotes diet & weight loss. Right? It’s actually more than that. Here’s a definition from Aubrey Gordon, author of “What We Don’t Talk About When We Talk About Fat”: Diet Culture: “A system of cultural beliefs and practices that equates thinness not just with health, but with moral virtue, and which advocates for weight loss at any cost. Diet culture isn’t just a matter of being on a diet, but of the social forces that make dieting (or lifestyle changes or wellness) culturally mandatory for so many of us.” The key phrases are “moral virtue” and “weight loss at any cost”. Diet culture doesn’t only convince us that weight loss is necessary (to be beautiful, to demonstrate our worth, or to be healthy); but it creates this pressure that we are MORALLY obligated to do so. In order to be perceived as good, responsible people, Diet Culture urges us to pursue weight loss at any cost- which could mean sacrificing our social life, a significant amount of money on supplements or meal replacements or programs, our emotional wellbeing, and even our physical wellbeing. Maybe diet and weight loss aren’t so healthy after all… And while this may not be everyone’s experience, we have research that demonstrates the following emotional impacts of restrictive dieting: Dieting is associated with higher anxiety levels (Kwasnicka, 2020) Dieting is associated with poorer emotional and mental quality of life (Burns etal, 2001) Dieting is linked with reduced life satisfaction (Esch and Zullig, 2013) Further, restrictive dieting has actually been found to cause weight GAIN. To be clear, weight gain is nothing to be ashamed about (bodies change!); but if the multibillion dollar diet industry is selling a diet plan for weight loss, they’re not exactly being honest about the likely outcomes. 1⁄3 to 2⁄3 regained weight within 1 year, with almost all weight regained within 5 years (1992 NIH Consensus) Most weight is gained back within 2 years and most gained back all the weight by 5 years (2013 Australian Research Council) A team of UCLA researchers reviewed 31 long term studies on the effectiveness of dieting and concluded that dieting is a consistent predictor of weight gain —up to two-thirds of the people regained more weight than they lost (Mann 2007) This quote from Weight Watchers former Finance Director sums it up pretty well:
07 Mar, 2022
Good morning! Thank you to everyone who came out to Break the Diet Cycle presentation. I hope you’re starting today feeling curious about Intuitive Eating and eager to rediscover your favorite foods in a fresh, positive way. I attached the PDFs of the presentation for you to reference, as well as the “HAES (Health at Every Size) Manifesto”, by Dr. Lindo Bacon, author of Health at Every Size. This provides a snapshot of the science behind the weight neutral approach, Health at Every Size, which Intuitive Eating is aligned with. For those of you who couldn’t attend, you may be wondering- what exactly is Intuitive Eating? As I mentioned in an earlier newsletter, Intuitive Eating is a non-diet approach to food and health. The framework consists of 10 principles to help you examine and reevaluate your beliefs & attitudes about your body, your food, physical activity, health, and more. While practicing Intuitive Eating, individuals relearn how to eat in accordance to their natural hunger and fullness cues; food cravings; energy needs, and so on. They begin to trust their body to tell them when to eat, what to eat, and how much to eat. The Ten Principles of Intuitive Eating are: 1. Reject the Diet Mentality 2. Honor Your Hunger 3. Make Peace with Food 4. Challenge the Food Police 5. Feel Your Fullness 6. Discover the Satisfaction actor 7. Cope with Your Feelings without Using Food 8. Respect Your Body 9. Exercise to Feel the Difference 10. Honor Your Health with Gentle Nutrition Intuitive Eating may seem like a straightforward concept, but in a culture that heavily promotes dieting and weight loss as a path to health, happiness, and even moral virtue, it can be hard to break out of the Diet Cycle (seen below). Also known as the “Restrict-Binge Cycle”, this eating pattern is typically kicked off by some diet thought, like “I need to lose weight” or “I need to start eating better”.
25 Jan, 2022
Snack Break with Mary Registered Dietitian-Nutritionist & Certified Intuitive Eating Counselor at Advantage Strength
By Brian Sipotz 10 Dec, 2020
It’s winter, and sometimes there’s nothing more satisfying than enjoying a warm bowl of soup. Sure, you can look up any recipe online or follow the recipes on this site to a T, but at some point you’re going to find yourself standing in your kitchen with little time, a bunch of random ingredients, and […]
By Brian Sipotz 24 Nov, 2020
Today I’m joined by Eva Solomon, Founder and CEO of Epic Races in Ann Arbor. Of course, an Epic Race looks different today than it did 8 months ago. With COVID-19, there is no opportunity to get 3,000 people together for the Ann Arbor marathon, so Eva and her staff have had to be creative. […]
By Brian Sipotz 24 Nov, 2020
Farmers markets and farm stands are growing in popularity as people start to see the value in fresh, local foods that support good health, good people (the farmers), and good communities. Today I enjoy a conversation with Tom and Vicki Zilke of Zilke Farm Stand (zilkevegetablefarm.com) and Zilke Farm Kitchen (zilkefarmkitchen.com), both located in Milan, […]
By Brian Sipotz 28 Sep, 2020
I’m embarrassed to admit I got lost this morning.   Picture this. Me standing in the middle of a corn maze, looking around at 8 different openings. I had absolutely no idea which way to go.   I stood there for 10 minutes, looking at all these different “doors” and trying to figure out which […]
By Brian Sipotz 30 Dec, 2018
Hard to believe, but 2018 is coming to a close and it’s time to pick another Word of the Year! This tradition started back in 2013 with the word Mindset, and it’s something I’ve done every year as a way to look back at what was most important for the last 12 months. Every year, […]
By Brian Sipotz 20 May, 2018
So you’re doing your best to eat better. You have the basic idea-  lean protein, veggies, and maybe a smart carb choice with every meal- but now it’s Thursday night and you are staring down the barrel of a 4th night in a row of eating chicken breasts with broccoli (because you prepped a bunch […]
By Brian Sipotz 03 May, 2018
Planning on heading out to use up some energy this weekend? Going out for a hike or a bike? Got long day of gardening ahead of you? Heading into Advantage for an action packed workout maybe? 🙂 Whatever you are planning on doing, plan on making a batch of these to take with you. Last […]
More Posts
Share by: